Premodern Concordance
Concept

Genius

Exceptional natural intellectual or creative capacity, including historically explicit accounts of natural genius.

Sources
21
Passages
38
In this corpus
16461920

Candidate findings

What the corpus suggests

Patterns synthesized only from the linked claims below. Each remains a research lead, not a substitute for reading the passages.

recurrence

The definition of genius as situational discernment

Multiple passages by William James consistently define a person of genius as one who can identify and extract the essential or correct element from a complex situation or emergency.

supports · William James, 1879
The man of genius is he who will always stick-in his bill, as it were, at the right point, and bring it out with the right element -- "reason" if the emergency be theoretical, "means" if it be practical-transfixed upon it?
Are We Automata?
supports · William James, 1890
The man of genius is he who will always stick in his bill at the right point, and bring it out with the right element — ‘reason’ if the emergency be theoretical, ‘means’ if it be practical — transfixed upon it.
The Principles of Psychology
supports · William James, 1892
The man of genius is he who will always stick in his bill at the right point, and bring it out with the right element— ‘reason’ if the emergency be theoretical, ‘means’ if it be practical — transfixed upon it.
Psychology (Briefer Course)
disagreement

Causality between genius and sustained attention

While common belief holds that sustained attention is a trait that defines or creates a genius, William James argues that genius is the underlying cause that makes an individual attentive.

supports · William James, 1890
But it is their genius making them attentive, not their attention making geniuses of them.
The Principles of Psychology
contradicts · William James, 1890
Geniuses are commonly believed to excel other men in their power of sustained attention.
The Principles of Psychology
supports · William James, 1892
But it is their genius making them attentive, not their attention making geniuses of them.
Psychology (Briefer Course)
qualification

The role of psychopathic temperament in effective genius

William James qualifies the general notion of genius by noting that while nervous instability is common, the most effective genius arises specifically when a psychopathic temperament coalesces with superior intellect.

supports · William James, 1902
Thus, when a superior intellect and a psychopathic temperament coalesce — as in the endless permutations and combinations of human faculty, they are bound to coalesce often enough — in the same individual, we have the best possible condition for the kind of effective genius that gets into the biographical dictionaries.
The Varieties of Religious Experience
qualifies · William James, 1902
such religious geniuses have often shown symptoms of nervous instability.
The Varieties of Religious Experience
sense shift

Evolution of genius from divine disposition to psychological trait

The concept shifts from Thomas Browne's 17th-century view of genius as a divinely ordained natural disposition for worldly functions to William James's 19th-century focus on psychological temperament and cognitive capacity.

supports · Thomas Browne, 1646
For the Wisdom of God hath divided the _Genius_ of men according to the different affairs of the World: and varied their inclination according to the variety of Actions to be performed therein
Pseudodoxia Epidemica
supports · William James, 1902
Thus, when a superior intellect and a psychopathic temperament coalesce — as in the endless permutations and combinations of human faculty, they are bound to coalesce often enough — in the same individual, we have the best possible condition for the kind of effective genius that gets into the biographical dictionaries.
The Varieties of Religious Experience

Names and forms

Term history

Geniuspreferred label
geniusesorthographic variantSuggested

Meanings in context

Senses in this corpus

Divinely ordained natural disposition

An innate, divinely granted intellectual or functional capacity suited to specific worldly tasks.

1 passage

Inherent rational sovereignty

Genius as an inwardly generated, rational sovereignty inherent to the human selfhood.

1 passage

Exceptional intellectual or creative capacity

A general designation for individuals possessing superior intellectual, creative, or spiritual abilities.

9 passages

Capacity for situational discernment

The intellectual ability to identify and extract the correct or essential elements for reasoning in any given situation.

3 passages

Psychological and temperamental traits

Exceptional intellectual capacity linked to specific psychological states, such as sustained attention, nervous instability, or psychopathic temperament.

5 passages

Analyzed source evidence

Historical usages and claims

Distinct local senses and assertions recovered from the corpus. Quotations retain the source OCR and link to the full passage and scan.

Pseudodoxia EpidemicaThomas Browne, 1646
same entry

The innate, divinely ordained intellectual or functional disposition of an individual suited to specific worldly tasks.

For the Wisdom of God hath divided the _Genius_ of men according to the different affairs of the World: and varied their inclination according to the variety of Actions to be performed therein

The distribution of natural genius among men is divinely ordained to suit different worldly functions.

asserts · reasoning · origin distribution

Failure to align one's profession with their natural genius leads to personal dishonor and social disorder.

asserts · reasoning · function use
Lectures and MiscellaniesHenry James Sr., 1852
same entry

Genius as an inwardly generated, rational sovereignty inherent to the human selfhood.

is a sovereignty of genius.

True sovereignty is defined as being a sovereignty of genius.

asserts · reasoning · definition

Genius is characterized as rational rather than mechanical.

asserts · reasoning · property
same entry

Exceptional intellectual capacity attributed to Swedenborg, characterized by his unique ability to internalize the relationship between God and man.

The incomparable depth and splendour of Swe- denborg’s genius are shewn in this, that he alone of men has ever dared to bring creation within the bounds of consciousness

Swedenborg's genius is uniquely characterized by his ability to bring creation within the bounds of human consciousness.

asserts · observation · property

Swedenborg's genius is distinguished from other writers by his interiorization of the relationship between object and subject.

asserts · reasoning · classification
same entry

Refers to an individual's innate, inherited intellectual or spiritual capacity as distinct from their true selfhood.

As to my natural or inherited genius, I may be as guileless and harmless as all the lambs and doves extant

Natural genius is inherited and distinct from an individual's true, spontaneous selfhood.

asserts · reasoning · property
same entry

Exceptional intellectual capacity demonstrated by the independent mathematical discovery of the planet Neptune.

The honour of this admirable effort of genius is shared by Mr. Adams and M. Le Verrier

The mathematical discovery of Neptune is classified as an effort of genius.

asserts · observation · classification

Adams and Le Verrier are identified as the individuals possessing the genius behind the discovery.

asserts · observation · identity
Are We Automata?William James, 1879
same entry

A person possessing the intellectual capacity to select the correct elements for reasoning in any given situation.

The man of genius is he who will always stick-in his bill, as it were, at the right point, and bring it out with the right element

Genius is defined by the ability to select the correct element from a phenomenon to reach a conclusion.

asserts · reasoning · definition
The Principles of PsychologyWilliam James, 1890
same entry

A person possessing the intellectual capacity to identify and extract the essential elements of a situation.

The man of genius is he who will always stick in his bill at the right point, and bring it out with the right element

A genius is defined by the ability to identify and extract the essential element of any given situation.

asserts · reasoning · definition
The Principles of PsychologyWilliam James, 1890
same entry

Individuals possessing exceptional intellectual capacity characterized by fertile minds and the ability to sustain attention.

Geniuses are commonly believed to excel other men in their power of sustained attention.

Geniuses are widely considered to possess a superior capacity for sustained attention compared to others.

reports · observation · property

The sustained attention of a genius is a result of their genius rather than the cause of it.

asserts · reasoning · mechanism
same entry

An individual possessing exceptional intellectual or creative capacity, used here as an example of mental reference.

He was a daring genius!

The term genius is used to describe a person of exceptional daring or ability.

asserts · reasoning · classification
Psychology (Briefer Course)William James, 1892
same entry

A person possessing the intellectual capacity to select the essential element for reasoning or practical action.

The man of genius is he who will always stick in his bill at the right point, and bring it out with the right element

Genius is defined by the ability to select the correct, relevant element from a complex phenomenon.

asserts · reasoning · definition
Psychology (Briefer Course)William James, 1892
same entry

Exceptional intellectual capacity characterized by fertile, spontaneous ideation that naturally sustains the individual's attention.

Geniuses are commonly believed to excel other men in their power of sustained attention. In most of them, it is to be feared, the so-called ‘power’ is of the passive sort. Their ideas coruscate, eve

The author argues that genius causes sustained attention rather than sustained attention causing genius.

asserts · reasoning · causal effect

The power of sustained attention in geniuses is often passive, driven by the fertile nature of their ideas.

asserts · observation · property
same entry

Refers to individuals possessing exceptional intellectual or creative capacity within an educational or social organization.

Having so favorable an organization, all we need is to impregnate it with geniuses, to get superior men and women working more and more abundantly in it and for it and at it

The presence of geniuses in an organization is a necessary condition for achieving educational leadership.

asserts · reasoning · function use
same entry

Individuals possessing exceptional religious capacity, often associated with nervous instability and abnormal psychical experiences.

But such individuals are “geniuses” in the religious line; and like many other geniuses who have brought forth fruits effective enough for commemoration in the pages of biography, such religious geniuses have often shown symptoms of nervous instability.

Religious geniuses frequently exhibit symptoms of nervous instability.

asserts · observation · property

Pathological features in the careers of religious geniuses contribute to their religious authority and influence.

asserts · reasoning · causal effect
same entry

The combination of superior intellect and psychopathic temperament as a condition for effective, historically recognized genius.

Thus, when a superior intellect and a psychopathic temperament coalesce — as in the endless permutations and combinations of human faculty, they are bound to coalesce often enough — in the same individual, we have the best possible condition for the kind of effective genius that gets into the biographical dictionaries.

The combination of high intellect and psychopathic temperament produces effective genius.

asserts · reasoning · causal effect

Genius is characterized by an inability to remain a mere critic, instead acting upon ideas.

asserts · observation · property
Memories and StudiesWilliam James, 1911
same entry

Herbert Spencer is classified as a genius due to his intellectual persistence and discovery of universal evolution.

And his peculiar trick, a priggish infirmity in daily intercourse, of treating every smallest thing by abstract law, was here a merit. Add his sleuth-hound scent for what he was after, and his untiring pertinacity, to his priority in perceiving the one great truth and you fully justify the popular estimate of him as one of the world’s geniuses, in spite of the fact that the “temperament” of genius, so called, seems to have been so lacking in him.

Spencer is considered a genius because of his priority in identifying the universal principle of evolution and his persistent intellectual work.

asserts · reasoning · classification

Spencer lacked the stereotypical temperament typically associated with genius.

asserts · observation · property
Some Problems of PhilosophyWilliam James, 1911
same entry

Individuals possessing exceptional intellectual capacity who identified mathematical aspects of nature.

No one could have foreseen in advance the extraordinary fertility of the more insipid mathematical aspects which these geniuses ferreted out.

Geniuses possess the capacity to identify and extract mathematical aspects from nature.

asserts · observation · property
Essays in Radical EmpiricismWilliam James, 1912
same entry

An individual possessing exceptional natural intellectual capacity for linguistic precision and conceptual synthesis.

a man with a genius for finding the right word for things may hit upon some unifying and conciliating formula

A person with genius possesses an exceptional natural ability to identify the precise language for concepts.

asserts · observation · property
Collected Essays and ReviewsWilliam James, 1920
same entry

Individuals possessing exceptional intellectual or creative capacity who remain unrecognized or unappreciated by society.

In other countries, aristocratic misanthropes, dyspeptic pleasure-seekers, and unappreciated geniuses have existed, and their utterances never passed beyond the sphere of splenetic or pathetic individuality.

Geniuses exist in various countries outside of Germany.

asserts · observation · origin distribution

The utterances of unappreciated geniuses are limited to personal, individualistic expression.

asserts · reasoning · property

Primary-source evidence

Full passages, chronologically

The Secret of SwedenborgHenry James Sr., 1869
Suggested
Certainly we have no right after this to attribute to Swe- denborg an obscure or mystical conception of nature. Nature bears the same servile relation to the spiritual creation that a man's body bears to his soul, that the material of a house bears to the house itself, or that the substance of a statue bears to its form, namely, a merely quantifying, by no means a qualifving, relation. It fills out the spiritual creation, substantiates it, gives it subjective anchorage, fixity, or identification, incorpo- rates it, in a word, just as the marble incorporates the statue. For the statue is primarily an ideal form, affiliating itself to the artist's genius exclusively, and is only derivatively thence f a material existence. So I primarily am a spiritual form, that is to say, a form of affection and thought, directly affiliated to the creative love and wisdom; and what my body does is 26 THE SECEET OF SWEDENBOKG.
Are We Automata?William James, 1879
Suggested
If, now, leaving the empirical combination of objects, we ask how the mind proceeds rationally to connect them we find selection again to be omnipotent. In an article on "Brute and Human Intellect " in the Journal of Speculative Philosophy, July 1878, p. 236 I have tried to show that all Reasoning depends on the ability of the mind to break up the totality of the phenomenon reasoned about into partial factors or elements, and to pick out from among these the particular one which, in our given theoretical or practical emergency, may lead to the proper conclusion. Another predicament will need another conclusion, and require another element to be picked out. The man of genius is he who will always stick-in his bill, as it were, at the right point, and bring it out with the right element -- "reason" if the emergency be theoretical, "means" if it be practical-transfixed upon it? Association by similarity I have shown to be an important help to this breaking-up of represented things into their elements. But this association is only the minimum of that same selection of which picking out the right reason is a maximum. I here confine myself to this brief statement, but it may suffice to show that Reasoning is but another form of that selective activity which appears to be the true sphere of mental spontaneity.
Suggested
of their own, and so disqualify science. But because miracle is disowned by science as an answer to her physical interrogations, we are not justified, nor ever shall be, in excluding it from philosophic recognition, as in truth the most efficient factor in the history of human nature. For philosophy unlike science has no interest in physics as a literal fact, but only as a spirit ual symbol, and is no way disconcerted therefore when you deny miracle a place and function in physical order. She has never been disposed to assign it such place and function, but on the contrary has expressly relegated it to spiritual or metaphysical uses. No man of philosophic genius, that is, no lover of truth for truth's own sake, has ever dreamt of finding a place or function for miracle in reference to physics, or the fixed statics of the mind, and has allowed it at most in reference to history, or its living dynamics and outcome. Every such man unfeignedly reverences miracle under this reserve, because in the long spir itual night of the mind when all knowledge of Divine things was obscured under the pall of men's mental and material penury, it alone shone as a feeble but prophetic day-star from on high to lift men's faith and hope out of an every way lifeless and ignominious present, and fix them on a living and radiant future big with God's unimaginable mercy. Thus miracle has always spoken to the free or spontaneous mind of
Suggested
descendants of the church, thus styled Adam or Man, as inclining to selfhood: that is, desiring to become instead of an internal man an external one. But he does not fail to characterize this change of genius in it, though relatively unfortunate of course, since everything deteriorates in proportion as it becomes remote from its source, yet as by no means absolutely so; inasmuch as selfhood, though regarded in itself or absolutely it is unmixed evil, is yet the indis pensable condition of man's natural development, or race-evolution, and consequently of that redemptive achievement in our nature which constitutes God's true or eternal spiritual glory in creation. This rising inclination to selfhood is the inevitable dawn of the natural or race-mind in us, and as such of course is noway evil, though viewed apart from that subordination it is the fountain of all the evil known to the universe. We don't get angry with the infant, although we feel bound in the interests of his own maturity to correct him, when we see him instinc tively exhibiting the traits of his future natural man hood; on the contrary we are secretly diverted by his arch and graceful ways of self-assertion, because as yet they are full of innocence or innocuous. Ex actly so we may say there is no ground for moral disapprobation in these nascent or unconscious ego tistic inclinations on the part of the early church,
" We laugh, as I said awhile ago, at an inventor who should ask us to take his genius on trust, or without any evidence of its reality. And there can be no more offensive tribute to the divine name than to show him a deference we deny to the rankest charlatan. How infinitely unworthy of God it would be to exact or expect of the absolute and unintelligent creatures of his power av belief out of all proportion to their sensible knowl- 1 edge, or unbacked by anything but tradition!... I am free to confess for my own part that I have no belief in God's absolute or irrelative and un- j -^ conditional perfection. I have not the least sentiment of worship for his name, the least sentiment of awe or reverence towards him, considered as a perfect person sufficient unto himself. That, style of deity exerts no attraction either upon my | heart or understanding. Any mother who suckles her babe upon her own breast, any bitch in fact who litters her periodical brood of pups, presents to my imagination a vastly nearer and sweeter
The Principles of PsychologyWilliam James, 1890
Suggested
The man of genius is he who will always stick in his bill at the right point, and bring it out with the right element — ‘reason’ if the emergency be theoretical, ‘means’ if it be practical — transfixed upon it. I here confine myself to this brief statement, but it may suffice to show that Reasoning is but another form of the selective activity of the mind. If now we pass to its æsthetic department, our law is still more obvious. The artist notoriously selects his items, rejecting all tones, colors, shapes, which do not harmonize with each other and with the main purpose of his work. That unity, harmony, ‘convergence of characters,’ as M. Taine calls it, which gives to works of art their superiority over works of nature, is wholly due to elimination. Any natural subject will do, if the artist has wit enough to pounce upon some one feature of it as characteristic, and suppress all merely accidental items which do not harmonize with this.
The Principles of PsychologyWilliam James, 1890
Suggested
And now we can see why it is that what is called sustained attention is the easier, the richer in acquisitions and the fresher and more original the mind. In such minds, subjects bud and sprout and grow At every moment, they please by a new consequence and rivet the attention afresh. But an intellect unfurnished with materials, stagnant, unoriginal, will hardly be likely to consider any subject long. A glance exhausts its possibilities of interest. Geniuses are commonly believed to excel other men in their power of sustained attention.23 In most of them, it is to be feared, the so-called ‘power’ is of the passive sort. Their ideas coruscate, every subject branches infinitely before their fertile minds, and so for hours they may be rapt. But it is their genius making them attentive, not their attention making geniuses of them. And, when we come down to the root of the matter, we see that they differ from ordinary men less in the character of their attention than in the nature of the objects upon which it is successively bestowed. In the genius, these form a concatenated series, suggesting each other mutually by some rational law. Therefore we call the attention ‘sustained’ and the topic of meditation for hours ‘the same.’ In the common man the series is for the most part incoherent, the objects have no rational bond, and we call the attention wandering and unfixed.
mean much more than actually is present to the thought of which he is reporter. Thus, for example, suppose you should go on to think: 'He was a daring genius!' An ordinary psychologist would not hesitate to say that the object of your thought was still 'Columbus.' True, your thought is _about_ Columbus. It
leads from and to the direct idea of Columbus. But for the moment it is not fully and immediately Columbus, it is only 'he,' or rather 'he-was-a-daring-genius;' which, though it may be an unimportant difference for conversational purposes, is, for introspective psychology, as great a difference as there can
Psychology (Briefer Course)William James, 1892
Suggested
If now, leaving the empirical combination of objects, we ask how the mind proceeds rationally to connect them, we find selection again to be omnipotent. In a future chapter we shall see that all Reasoning depends on the ability of the mind to break up the totality of the phenomenon reasoned about, into parts, and to pick out from among these the particular one which, in the given emergency, may lead to the proper conclusion. The man of genius is he who will always stick in his bill at the right point, and bring it out with the right element— ‘reason’ if the emergency be theoretical, ‘means’ if it be practical — transfixed upon it. If now we pass to the æsthetic department, our law is still more obvious. The artist notoriously selects his items, rejecting all tones, colors, shapes, which do not harmonize with each other and with the main purpose of his work. That unity, harmony, ‘convergence of characters,’ as M.